Skip to Content

Discover The First Animal On Earth

The comb jelly.
The comb jelly. Image by Jonathan Diemel via Unsplash

The quest to discover Earth’s first animal is a journey through deep time. It leads us to ancient seas where life began its complex dance. The debate centers on two candidates: sponges and comb jellies. Fossils and genetic studies offer clues, yet the answer remains elusive. Let’s explore the evidence that brings us closer to understanding this mystery.

The Role of Fossils

Many trilobite fossils in a slab of stone.
Many trilobite fossils in a slab of stone. Image by Wes Warren via Unsplash

During the Cambrian explosion, many animals evolved, including trilobites. Fossils are our primary window into the past. They tell the story of life on Earth. The Cambrian period, starting around 541 million years ago, offers the first solid evidence of complex animals. Fossils from this era show a wide variety of life forms. However, these creatures had ancestors, and understanding these predecessors is crucial to our search.

The Cambrian Explosion

A starfish (or seastar) fossil, with a trilobite fossil.
A starfish (or seastar) fossil, with a trilobite fossil. Image by David Clode via Unsplash

The Cambrian Explosion was a pivotal moment in the history of life. In just 10 million years, a diverse array of animal species emerged. These organisms laid the foundation for all modern animal groups. Yet, the question remains: What sparked this sudden burst of life? The answer may lie in the earlier Ediacaran period, where the first animals might have appeared.

The Ediacaran Period

During the Ediacaran explosion, many animals evolved, including Dickinsonia.
During the Ediacaran explosion, many animals evolved, including Dickinsonia. Image by Verisimilus at English Wikipedia, CC BY 2.5, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=3262792

The Ediacaran period, which preceded the Cambrian, was a time of soft-bodied organisms. These creatures left behind few fossils, making it hard to study them. Among the known species is Dickinsonia, a wormlike organism with ribbed segments. The scarcity of fossils from this time makes it challenging to determine if these were the first animals.

The Challenge of Soft-Bodied Fossils

Sea sponge
Sea sponge on the seafloor. Image by Feri Tasos via Unsplash

Soft-bodied organisms are less likely to fossilize than those with hard parts. This makes studying early life particularly difficult. Many of the earliest animals may have left little or no trace. Scientists must rely on indirect evidence, such as chemical signatures in rocks, to infer the presence of these ancient creatures.

The Oldest Known Animal Fossil

A fossil sponge
A fossil sponge. Image by Wilson44691 – Own work, CC0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=41427558, via Wikimedia Commons

In 2021, a study proposed the discovery of the oldest known animal fossil, an 890-million-year-old sponge. This finding is significant, but it’s not without controversy. Some scientists question whether this fossil truly represents an animal. The debate highlights the challenges of studying life from such a distant past.

Molecular Clock Studies

Comb jelly showing off its light show.
Comb jelly showing off its light show. Image via Depositphotos

In addition to fossils, scientists use genetic techniques to trace the origins of life. The molecular clock method estimates when different species diverged based on genetic mutations. A recent study suggested that comb jellies, not sponges, might be the first animals, dating back around 600 to 700 million years. However, this theory is also debated.

The Case for Sponges

sponge
Sponge surrounded by fish. Image by fenkieandreas via Depositphotos

Sponges are among the simplest animals. They filter feed, lacking the complex systems found in other organisms. Some scientists argue that sponges are the most likely candidates for the first animals. Their simplicity could represent the earliest form of animal life, from which more complex forms evolved.

The Case for Comb Jellies

Comb jelly swimming in the dark.
Comb jelly swimming in the dark. Image via Depositphotos

Comb jellies, also known as ctenophores, are more complex than sponges. They have muscular and nervous systems. Recent studies suggest they could be the earliest animals. However, their complexity raises questions. Could such advanced features have evolved so early? This debate continues as new evidence emerges.

The Importance of Biomineralization

Ctenophores, comb jelly.
Ctenophores, comb jelly. Image via Depositphotos

Biomineralization, where animals’ organic matter influences mineral formation, is another key piece of the puzzle. The earliest known biomineralization dates to around 750 million years ago. If animals existed earlier, we would expect to find evidence of this process. The absence of such evidence complicates the timeline of animal evolution.

The Evolutionary Process

Sea sponge. Image by Noaa via Unsplash

Evolution is a gradual process. Complex animals did not suddenly appear; they evolved from simpler forms. This is why some scientists favor sponges as the first animals. Their simplicity fits the pattern of gradual evolution. However, the exact path of evolution remains unclear, and both sponges and comb jellies are still in the running.

Conclusion

Comb jelly, invader to the Black Sea.
Comb jelly, invader to the Black Sea. Image via Depositphotos

The search for Earth’s first animal is far from over. Fossils and genetic studies provide valuable clues, but the answer remains elusive. Whether sponges or comb jellies hold the title, their existence marks the beginning of a remarkable journey. Understanding the origins of animal life helps us appreciate the complexity and diversity of life on our planet.

Latest posts by Jen Fitschen, BSc Computer Science and Oceanography (see all)
Unusual Fall Season For Almost All US States Predicted Spotting A Blue Jay May Be The Universe’s Way Of Telling You What You Need New York Rescue Duck Found Himself An Emotional Support Duck Spotting A Cougar May Be The Universe’s Way Of Telling You What You Need Do Bald Eagles Mate For Life?