Skip to Content

Polar Bears Make a UK Comeback After Over 20 Years – But Is It the Right Choice?

Polar Bears Make a UK Comeback After Over 20 Years - But Is It the Right Choice?
Sailors visit the polar bear enclosure at London zoo in 1930. Below: a bear at Dudley Zoo in Worcestershire, 1937 (left), and Brumas, the first baby polar bear to be successfully reared in the UK, at London Zoo in 1950. Photographs: Fox/Getty Images; Mirrorpix

Polar bears, once nearly absent from the United Kingdom, are making a surprising comeback. From Jimmy’s Farm in Suffolk to wildlife parks across the country, these majestic Arctic predators are capturing public attention and sparking debates about their place in captivity. With a climate crisis threatening their wild habitats, the question remains: Is keeping polar bears in enclosures a solution or a misstep?

A Startling Sight in Suffolk

Polar Bears Make a UK Comeback After Over 20 Years - But Is It the Right Choice?
Flocke and her daughter Tala, who were relocated to Jimmy’s Farm in Suffolk from Yorkshire Wildlife Park. Photograph: Joshua Bright/The Guardian

Passengers traveling on the Ipswich-London train often do double-takes as they spot polar bears roaming across a meadow at Jimmy’s Farm. Once unthinkable, polar bears are now part of this wildlife park’s diverse animal population. Jimmy Doherty, the farm’s owner and a conservationist, has built one of the largest polar bear enclosures in Europe, providing the bears with expansive woodland, deep pools, and shaded areas to replicate a more natural habitat.

The Comeback of Captive Polar Bears

Polar Bears Make a UK Comeback After Over 20 Years - But Is It the Right Choice?
Ewa enjoying a carrot in the autumn sunshine. Photograph: Joshua Bright/The Guardian

By 2000, just one polar bear remained in Britain, reflecting changing attitudes against keeping these far-roaming animals in restrictive zoo enclosures. However, a resurgence began in recent years as polar bears were reintroduced to facilities with more spacious and enriched environments. Today, 16 polar bears live in four wildlife parks across the UK, including Jimmy’s Farm, which houses four.

A Mission of Rescue and Care

Polar Bears Make a UK Comeback After Over 20 Years - But Is It the Right Choice?
A polar bear in its cage at London Zoo, 1960. Photograph: Frederick Wilfred

Jimmy’s Farm became home to polar bears when Sweden’s Orsa Predator Park closed in 2022. Doherty rescued two bears, Ewa and her cub Miki, just before they faced euthanasia. While Miki tragically died of an undiagnosed heart condition, Ewa has thrived in her new environment. She now lives with three other polar bears, all rescued under similar circumstances.

Doherty emphasizes his mission to provide space and choice for the animals. “They can walk in the woods, dive into deep lakes, or relax in dens—it’s their choice,” he explains.

Challenges of Captivity

Polar Bears Make a UK Comeback After Over 20 Years - But Is It the Right Choice?
Tala cools off in Jimmy’s pond. Photograph: Joshua Bright/The Guardian

Despite improvements in enclosure design, critics argue that captivity remains unsuitable for polar bears. The Born Free Foundation points to issues like stress, shortened lifespans, and high infant mortality rates in captive bears. Chris Lewis from Born Free notes, “There’s no meaningful conservation benefit to keeping polar bears in captivity. Conservation action must address climate change and habitat loss in the wild.”

Conservation Breeding Programs

Polar Bears Make a UK Comeback After Over 20 Years - But Is It the Right Choice?
Ewa at Jimmy’s Farm, unperturbed by a passing Ipswich-London train. Photograph: Joshua Bright/The Guardian

Polar bears in the UK are part of the European Endangered Species Programme (EEP), which aims to maintain a genetically viable captive population. While critics doubt the feasibility of reintroducing captive bears into the wild, supporters argue that retaining a healthy population provides a last-resort option for species survival.

Adapting to Suffolk’s Climate

Polar Bears Make a UK Comeback After Over 20 Years - But Is It the Right Choice?
Tala cools off in Jimmy’s pond. Photograph: Joshua Bright/The Guardian

The bears at Jimmy’s Farm have adjusted well to Suffolk’s climate, which is similar to summer conditions in parts of the Arctic. Woodland areas and deep pools help the bears regulate their temperature, and enrichment activities such as foraging, whole-carcass feeding, and seasonal diets keep them mentally and physically stimulated.

A New Model for Polar Bear Enclosures

Polar bear in captivity.
Polar bear in captivity. Image by Regisser_com via Depositphotos.

Modern enclosures like Jimmy’s Farm and Highland Wildlife Park represent a shift from the concrete cages of the past. Douglas Richardson, a polar bear enclosure expert, designed cost-effective, spacious enclosures using reinforced deer fencing. These designs provide more naturalistic environments, helping reduce stress and improve the well-being of captive bears.

The Ethical Dilemma

polar bear
The massive paws of a Polar Bear. Image by sunworld via Depositphotos

While polar bears in captivity can raise awareness and funds for conservation, their presence in enclosures remains controversial. Critics argue that the focus should be on addressing the climate crisis, pollution, and human encroachment, which pose the greatest threats to wild polar bear populations.

Looking Ahead

polar bear
Polar bear poking his nose out of his icey den. Image by SURZet via Depositphotos

Doherty isn’t ruling out breeding polar bears in the future, should conservation needs demand it. Meanwhile, he continues to rescue animals in need, recently crowdfunding to save brown bears from Sweden and Romania.

A Complex Relationship

Polar bear in captivity.
Polar bear in captivity. Image by nm737 via Depositphotos.

The return of polar bears to Britain highlights the complex relationship between conservation and captivity. While modern enclosures offer better care, they cannot fully replicate the vast Arctic expanses these animals need. As climate change accelerates, the fate of polar bears—both in captivity and in the wild—depends on global efforts to protect their habitats and address the root causes of their decline.

In the meantime, Jimmy’s Farm and other wildlife parks provide a glimpse into the challenges and possibilities of coexisting with one of nature’s most iconic predators.