Skip to Content

Sad and Confused Puppy Returned to Shelter Because She Wasn’t Potty Trained

Puppy returned to shelter because she wasn't potty trained.
Puppy returned to shelter because she wasn't potty trained. Image by @animalhouseshelter via TikTok.

Finding a loving home is every dog’s dream, but for some, this journey is riddled with pain and rejection. Lilah, a sweet puppy from Huntley, Illinois, has experienced more than her fair share of heartbreak. Her story began at Animal House Shelter, a no-kill shelter where she was waiting for a forever family to whisk her away into a life of love and comfort. But Lilah’s path has been anything but easy.

A Short-Lived Adoption

Puppy heartbroken after being returned to shelter.
Puppy heartbroken after being returned to shelter. Image by @animalhouseshelter via TikTok.

In June 2024, Lilah’s tail wagged with joy as she was finally adopted. For the staff at the shelter, it was a moment of excitement. Lilah had been through so much already—rescued in February from a pound in southern Illinois along with her siblings, she had watched as every one of them found their new families while she was left behind. But now, finally, it was her turn.

Her new family seemed like a perfect match. Lilah was thrilled, and the shelter staff had high hopes. But just a month later, that glimmer of hope dimmed. Lilah was brought back to the shelter. The reason? She wasn’t potty trained. The disappointment was palpable, and the heartbreak, unbearable. 

She Just Needed to Be Trained

Puppy returned to shelter just needed to be trained.
Puppy returned to shelter just needed to be trained. Image by @animalhouseshelter via TikTok.

Tabitha, one of the compassionate staff members at the shelter, spoke of Lilah’s unfortunate return with a heavy heart. “They knew she wasn’t potty trained when they adopted her,” Tabitha explained, frustration and sadness mixing in her words. The foster family had been upfront about Lilah’s accidents—two a day, typical for a young puppy still learning the ropes. “She’s just a baby. She needs training, patience, and love,” Tabitha said.

But patience was something Lilah’s new family didn’t seem to have. And so, after less than a month of being in a home, Lilah found herself back in her cold kennel alone, her heart broken. 

A Confusing Return

Puppy clings to favorite toy after being returned to shelter.
Puppy clings to favorite toy after being returned to shelter. Image by @animalhouseshelter via TikTok.

For Lilah, the confusion was overwhelming. She had thought she found her forever home, a place where she could finally rest easy and be loved. But now she was back, sitting in her cage with her favorite toy, wondering what went wrong. “She just sat there, holding her toy, whining,” Tabitha shared. “She didn’t understand why she was back.”

The shelter, once again, became her home—a place that was supposed to be temporary but felt more and more permanent with each passing day. The shelter staff did their best to comfort her, offering her toys and introducing her to new doggy friends. Lilah, ever the resilient spirit, slowly began to adjust, her bright personality shining through despite multiple heartbreaks and rejection.

Hope for a Brighter Future

Puppy returned to shelter still hoping to find forever home.
Puppy returned to shelter still hoping to find forever home. Image by @AnimalHouseShelter via Facebook.

Though Lilah’s journey has been rough, the shelter staff remains hopeful. They know Lilah is a special dog—a dog who just needs the right family to see her for who she is: loving, playful, and eager to bond. “She loves kids, other dogs, and even gets along with cats,” Tabitha shared with a hopeful smile. “She deserves a family that can offer her patience and lots of love.”

Despite her past, Lilah hasn’t given up hope. Her sweet smile and gentle demeanor continue to melt the hearts of everyone she meets. And though she’s been returned twice already, her spirit remains unbroken. 

For Lilah, the right family is out there somewhere. The staff believes it’s only a matter of time before she finds a home where she will never have to fear being returned again.

Unusual Fall Season For Almost All US States Predicted Spotting A Blue Jay May Be The Universe’s Way Of Telling You What You Need New York Rescue Duck Found Himself An Emotional Support Duck Spotting A Cougar May Be The Universe’s Way Of Telling You What You Need Do Bald Eagles Mate For Life?