Skip to Content

Turns Out It Wasn’t a Comet That Wiped Out The Dinosaurs—And It Didn’t Come from Jupiter

asteroid
Asteroid on its final journey. Image by magann via Depositphotos

For years, we thought a giant comet object smacked into Earth 66 million years ago, signing the collective death certificate of our planet’s dinosaurs. Most believed the murder weapon was either a comet or an asteroid, but there was always some mystery about where it came from. But get this! A new study proves it wasn’t a comet and didn’t come from anywhere near Jupiter like we initially thought. So strap in your asteroid belts and prepare to have your galaxy brain blown!

The Cosmic Mystery of The Impact

Chicxulub impact - artist impression
Chicxulub impact – artist impression. Image by Donald E. Davis, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The dino deathblow occurred 66 million years ago in what is now Mexico’s Yucatan Peninsula. This created a huge crater called Chicxulub. The aftermath was something out of an apocalypse-themed action movie. The crash triggered massive tsunamis, and raging fires, while a dust cloud blocked out sunlight. It created an environment so harsh that most lives didn’t survive. While the effects of the impact are well-known, the true nature of the object responsible has remained a mystery—until now.

Comet vs Asteroid: A Lightyear-long Debate

comet
Comet racing through space. Image by Edu INAF, photographer: Alessandro Bianconi, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Scientists have long debated whether a comet or an asteroid caused the extinction. Now it may seem as unimportant as debating whether to wear jeans or leggings, but the distinction could help us understand the risks of future impacts. It seems we have more than alien invasions to worry about! While comets are icy and come from far away in the solar system, asteroids are usually rocky and come from much closer. That’s why Jupiter’s asteroids seemed a likely suspect.

The Surprising Answer

Asteroid
Asteroid. Image by NASA, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

A recent study published in Science has finally closed the case. Using advanced techniques, researchers discovered that the object was actually an asteroid, not a comet. And despite the evidence – it came from beyond Jupiter, deep in the outer solar system. Like a rare Pokemon this asteroid, called the carbonaceous asteroid, contains a higher amount of carbon compared to other types. It was this unusual composition that gave away its alien origin.

Debunking The Comet Theory

asteroid
Meteor breaking apart. Image by NASA JPL CalTech, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

In 2021, two Harvard scientists suggested that the Chicxulub impact might have been caused by a comet. They believed a stray comet got shredded by the Sun’s gravity which sent a deadly piece crashing to Earth. But in typical human fashion, they were wrong. According to new research, the asteroid’s composition simply didn’t match that of a comet. 

How Scientists Studied Ancient Rocks

Chicxulub Impact Crater
Chicxulub Impact Crater (top left), Gulf of Mexico, Image by O.V.E.R.V.I.E.W., CC BY 2.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

By studying ancient rock samples from the Chicxulub crater, researchers determined these rocks contain a rare element called ruthenium, which isn’t usually found on Earth. Scientists were able to determine the origin of the asteroid by analyzing the ruthenium isotopes in the rocks. The results were surprising!

The Proof Is In The Ruthenium

Ruthenium crystal
Ruthenium crystal. Image by Hi-Res Images of Chemical Elements, CC BY 3.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

By comparing ruthenium found in the Chicxulub rocks to different types of meteorites, scientists identified the asteroid as a “type C” carbonaceous asteroid. Unlike other asteroids, Carbonaceous asteroids are made of carbon and other volatile elements. These asteroids formed beyond Jupiter, where conditions are much colder and materials are more primitive. Most meteorites that fall to Earth are from “type S” asteroids, which are rocky and formed closer to the Sun. This discovery proved that this asteroid originated from a group of carbon-rich from much farther away in the solar system than most asteroids that hit Earth.

Is It All Part Of A Bigger Picture

shooting star
A shooting star seen in the night sky. Image by Eusebiu Soica via Pexel

This caused me to ponder a great many things. Could other mass extinctions have been caused by type C asteroids? According to Geochemist Mario Fischer-Gödde, the lead author of the study, it’s possible. They may have played a bigger part in shaping Earth’s history than we think. In fact, they might have helped bring life to Earth in the first place!

A Cosmic Water Balloon

asteroid
Asteroid belt. Image by Juric.P via Depositphotos

This type of asteroid could have brought water to Earth. Scientists have long believed that asteroids delivered water and organic materials to our planet in its early years. If this carbon-rich asteroid was part of that process, it could give us more clues about how life began on our planet. 

Eye Don’t Spy: Type C Asteroids

People Stargazing
Silhouette of Two People Stargazing. Image by Yuting Gao via Pexels

The discovery also has important implications for the future. If type C asteroids have caused mass extinctions in the past, just imagine the threat they would pose today! Especially since their faraway location in the solar system makes them harder to detect. If scientists don’t keep their telescopes peeled we the whole of humanity could be at risk. 

Are We Safe?

moon
Moon in a sky full of stars. Image by Min An via Pexels

These threats beyond your stars encourage scientists to look at other extinction events in a new light. Our dinosaurs weren’t just destroyed by a random comet, but by an asteroid fleeing from an outer solar system. It’s a wonder we haven’t developed an intergalactic security system. Or have we?

Surveying The Skies

Astronomer with telescope
Astronomer with a telescope. Image by milangucci via Depositphotos

Turns out space agencies around the world are already working on ways to detect and prevent asteroid impacts. But I honestly think we should be doing more. An asteroid could take us down faster than the wifi goes down! While this discovery helps us understand the past, it also highlights the importance of tracking potential space threats. We definitely need to learn more about space dangers to better prepare for future encounters. 

In Short

Scientists Now Know where the Asteroid that Wiped Out the Dinosaurs Came From
Dinosaurs escaping or dying because of heat and fire due to a big meteorite crash. Image via Depositphotos

Just because the dinosaurs were blindsided doesn’t mean we don’t have to be! This new research offers fresh insights into the extinction of our dinosaurs. By revealing that the Chicxulub impactor was a carbon-rich asteroid from beyond Jupiter, scientists not only left us starry-eyed but solved some of Earth’s greatest mysteries.

Unusual Fall Season For Almost All US States Predicted Spotting A Blue Jay May Be The Universe’s Way Of Telling You What You Need New York Rescue Duck Found Himself An Emotional Support Duck Spotting A Cougar May Be The Universe’s Way Of Telling You What You Need Do Bald Eagles Mate For Life?