Skip to Content

Why Young Orcas Are 4.5 Times More Likely to Die Without Their Grandmother

orca
Orca. Image by CoreyFord via Depositphotos.

Killer whales, or orcas (Orcinus orca), exhibit one of the most fascinating social structures in the animal kingdom. Among their many unique traits, one stands out: older female orcas play a crucial role in the survival of their pods, particularly their grandchildren. A groundbreaking study provides the first direct evidence of the “grandmother hypothesis” in a nonhuman species, showing that postreproductive female orcas increase the survival rates of their grand-offspring through resource sharing and leadership.

Understanding the Grandmother Hypothesis

Schwertwal – Orca / Killer whale / Orcinus orca

The grandmother hypothesis suggests that in certain species, females live long after their reproductive years to provide care and knowledge to younger generations. In humans, studies have shown that grandmothers help increase their grandchildren’s survival rates, especially in hunter-gatherer societies. Researchers have now discovered that killer whales follow a similar pattern, with elder females contributing to the survival of their pods long after they stop reproducing.

Why Do Female Orcas Live Beyond Their Reproductive Years?

orca
Jumping orca whale. Image by MennoSchaefer via Depositphotos

Unlike most mammals, female killer whales experience menopause, typically ceasing reproduction in their late 30s or early 40s, yet they can live past 100 years. Males, in contrast, have shorter lifespans and continue reproducing until death. This unusual longevity has intrigued scientists, prompting research into its evolutionary purpose.

The Study That Uncovered Orca Grandmother Behavior

Orca
Orca Killer Whale Calf surfaces in Antarctica, Greenland. Image via Depositphotos

A team of researchers analyzed decades of data on two populations of resident killer whales off the coast of Washington state and British Columbia. They tracked 378 orcas with known maternal grandmothers, using underwater cameras and long-term observational records to assess survival rates.

The results were striking: when a grandmother died, her grandchildren were 4.5 times more likely to die within the following two years. This effect was even more pronounced during periods of low Chinook salmon availability, the orcas’ primary food source.

How Grandmother Orcas Help Their Pods

Jumping orca whales Image by MennoSchaefer via Depositphotos
Breaching orca. Juan Islands. Image via Depositphotos

Scientists identified two key ways in which grandmother orcas contribute to their grand-offspring’s survival:

  1. Food Sharing – Grandmothers provide direct nutritional support by sharing their freshly caught salmon with younger family members, particularly in times of scarcity.
  2. Knowledge and Leadership – Older females possess a wealth of ecological knowledge, particularly about seasonal fish migrations and reliable hunting grounds. This guidance is crucial when food is scarce.

The Role of Grandmothers in Times of Scarcity

Image of an Orca’s tail

During years when Chinook salmon populations decline, survival becomes more difficult for orcas. Researchers found that grandmothers are particularly vital in these lean years, either by sharing their catches or leading younger pod members to better feeding locations. Their experience helps mitigate the effects of unpredictable food supplies, ensuring the survival of their lineage.

Do Both Male and Female Grand-Offspring Benefit Equally?

orcas swim past two kids
orcas swim past two kids. Image via Pexels

Surprisingly, the study found that both male and female young orcas benefited equally from having a living grandmother. This contradicts previous assumptions that male orcas might rely more on their mothers due to their lower hunting success compared to females. The findings suggest that grandmothers play an overarching role in pod survival, regardless of gender.

Why Do Older Females Stop Reproducing?

Wild orca TALKING to girl
Image of an Orca swimming through water via Pexels.

If survival hinges so much on elder females, why don’t they continue reproducing? Scientists propose that menopause in orcas may have evolved due to competition between generations. A 2017 study suggested that when multiple generations of female orcas breed simultaneously, the offspring of older mothers are less likely to survive due to competition for resources. This reproductive conflict might explain why older females shift their role from having calves to supporting their grand-offspring.

Similarities Between Orcas and Humans

orca
Image of a Wild Orca via Pexels

The presence of postreproductive females in orca societies mirrors human social structures, where grandmothers often play a vital role in child-rearing. Scientists speculate that this shared pattern might be an important evolutionary strategy for species with strong family bonds and complex social groups.

What Other Animals Experience Menopause?

orca
A Bigg’s orca whale jumping out of the sea in Vancouver Island, Canada. Image by Wirestock via Depositphotos

Apart from humans and killer whales, only a few other species experience menopause and extended postreproductive lifespans:

  • Short-finned pilot whales (Globicephala macrorhynchus)
  • Beluga whales (Delphinapterus leucas)
  • Narwhals (Monodon monoceros)

All of these species exhibit highly social behaviors where elder females may contribute knowledge and care to younger generations.

Implications for Orca Conservation

How and Why Orcas are Dominating False Bay
killer whale calf making high jump out of the water. Image by: ivkovich via Depositphotos

Understanding the role of grandmother orcas has major conservation implications. Southern resident killer whale populations are currently endangered, partly due to declining Chinook salmon stocks. If older females are key to younger whales’ survival, their loss could exacerbate population declines. Protecting older orcas might be just as important as increasing food supplies.

The Role of Chinook Salmon in Orca Survival

Orca
Orca. Image by JuRitt via Depositphotos

Since orcas are specialized predators, their survival is tightly linked to the availability of Chinook salmon. Declining fish populations due to overfishing, habitat destruction, and climate change directly affect orca survival rates. Conservation efforts aimed at restoring salmon populations could help maintain the delicate balance of orca family structures.

How Scientists Track Grandmother Whales

Two killer whales.Image by ivkovich via Depositphotos

Researchers use a combination of photo identification, drone footage, and genetic analysis to track individual orcas. Their distinctive dorsal fins and markings allow scientists to monitor family relationships over generations, revealing how grandmothers influence survival trends.

Can Grandmother Whales Teach Younger Generations?

Killer whale surround a seal.
Killer whale surround a seal. Image by Callan Carpenter, CC BY-SA 4.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Beyond sharing food, grandmother orcas may actively teach younger whales essential survival skills. Scientists are investigating whether orcas exhibit cultural transmission, where knowledge about hunting, migration, and social behaviors is passed down through generations.

What Happens When an Orca Pod Loses Its Elders?

Orca
Orcinus orca (Linnaeus, 1758), Killer whale; Loro Parque, Tenerife, Canary Islands, Spain. By H. Zell – Own work, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=71177905

When older females die, their families face increased survival challenges. Younger orcas must fend for themselves without the guidance of experienced hunters. This disruption in leadership may explain why juvenile mortality rates rise when grandmothers pass away.

Could Understanding Orca Grandmothers Help Us Understand Human Evolution?

Killer whale.
Killer whale. Image by Jerzystrzelecki, CC BY 3.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The grandmother hypothesis in orcas provides a unique model for studying the evolution of menopause. If menopause evolved in humans for similar reasons, it suggests that long postreproductive lifespans may be an adaptation to complex social structures, rather than just a byproduct of increased longevity.

The Future of Grandmother Orca Research

Killer whales.
Killer whales. Image by Robert Pittman, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

As research advances, scientists hope to uncover even more about the long-term impacts of grandmothers on killer whale populations. The study of social structures in marine mammals not only improves conservation efforts but also provides valuable insights into how intelligence and culture evolve in the animal kingdom.

Conclusion

Detail of orca – the killer whale. Image by anze.bizjan via Depositphotos

The grandmother effect in killer whales challenges traditional views on animal aging and social roles. These findings emphasize the crucial role of elder females in family survival, offering a rare glimpse into how postreproductive life stages can benefit an entire species. As research continues, the remarkable wisdom and leadership of grandmother orcas will likely reveal even deeper connections between humans and one of the ocean’s most intelligent predators.